![]() |
| Infant penis after circumcision |
![]() |
| Intact infant penis |
When we had our son we really didn’t put any thought into whether to get him circumcised. I left that decision up to my husband really. . We knew that there was no medical need for one. And our religion doesn’t make us do it. We thought that our son would have questions later in life about why he didn’t look like the other boys like that, or look like his daddy. To us it was just one of the things you just do with out any real thought. If it was good enough for me(my husband) then it is good for him.
Sarah's Story..
Once again, I am not attacking anyone or their beliefs, everyone has the right to choose what they think is best for their family. I may say some things that may offend some people, I just want to emphasize that this is not my intention, I am only saying what I feel, and I happen to feel a great deal for this topic, having a beautiful baby boy myself. I am going to touch on quite a few facts and myths about circumcision and will try to keep it short. But something tells me that it may fail me. But I will also include a selection of websites that I get my information from (other than just my personal beliefs) so you can check them out yourself in greater detail.
After I found out that I was pregnant with a boy the first thing that came into my mind was that I was going to have to make the decision whether or not I was going to have my son circumcised. I hadn't done any research about it at this time, but I didn't feel right with it. Something about it just didn't sit right with me. Like most mothers, I wanted to make sure that my son was happy when he grew older and was afraid of the idea of him being made fun of simply because his penis looked different from someone else's, not to mention that he would look different from his father. But the more I thought about it, I began to question whether or not it was worth putting my son through something so incredibly painful just because he MIGHT get made fun of. But I just put the thought to my side and told my husband that he is the one who is going to make the decision because I myself don't have a penis, so I didn't know if I was capable of making a decision that would have such an important impact in my sons life (not to mention that I just didn't want to feel guilty for the pain he was sure to feel). Thankfully, one day my sister Emily asked me if I was going to circumcise my son or not, and wondering why I chose what I did. When I told her that I was leaving it up to my husband she decided to send me a little bit of information on the whole process, and I couldn't have been more thankful to her. I, like most people, didn't think to research the pros and cons about it, I was just too focused on the taboo of uncircumcised men to think any further, and once I actually started to look at the facts, I was absolutely shocked at what I found.
When people find out that I left my son intact, the first thing they ask is "why?". To me, this is a little weird cause I have plenty of reasons, but answer me this, why did you get him circumcised? Most will give the whole it's cleaner, healthier, and better looking talk and I will just nod my head and say because what's done is done, so me saying anything wont change anything, it may only just start an argument. There are so many myths surrounding the uncircumcised, or intact, penis, I just don't know where to start. So bare with me as I try to write them all out, and please keep an open mind.
Myth #1- I'm pretty sure that one of the first things that come to your mind is that an uncircumcised penis is that it is dirty, nasy, and smelly. So I ask you this, if you are female, does your vagina smell? No? Probably because you clean it everytime you bathe, as you should. And your vagina hasn't been ciricumcised, but yet with the proper care and hygene, you remain smell free and probably don't think of yourself as dirty or nasty. Right about now you are probably thinking "But the vagina and foreskin of a male penis have nothing in common", but I beg to differ. Look un the dictionary under foreskin and tell me what you see. It says; Noun, the prepuce of the penis. Now go look up prepuce. What do you find? It says; Noun. 1 the fold of skin that covers the head of the penis; foreskin. 2 a similar covering of the clitorus. That says enough for me. It serves the same function on a female as it does a male, but you would never think about circumcising your little baby girl, would you? (which is a good thing seeing as how it is illegal in the US). When an intact male pees, the urine will flush out foreign microbes that may have gotten inside the foreskin. And in healthy people, urine is actually sterile and has a disinfectant quality, so when the urine passes through, it is actually cleaning itself. But even though pee passes through the foreskin every day, it is pretty much free of urea. Research has shown that the secretions of semial vecicles, prostate, and urethral mucous glads keep the foreskin clear and clean. It's the same concept as tears being the self-cleaning agent of your eye. So a penis left intact is naturally clean, and the view of the uncircumcised penis being dirty is compleletly unscientific. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says "Good personal hygiene would offer all the advantages of routine circumcision without the attendant surgical risk."
Myth #2- Many people have their infants circumcised, so it must be remcomended highly by medical officails. Think again. Circumcision actually isn't recomended by ANY national medical association in the entire world. Several medical associations have done many studies and found no evidence to support the practice. And when it comes to having newborns and infants circumcised, it is actually a recomendation to NOT have it done routinely, saying it is non-therapeutic.
Myth #3- People think that the foreskin doesn't serve any important function to the penis and that it's just a bit of "extra skin". Unfortunatly that isn't the case. The forskin contains about 10,000 highly specialized nerve endings and several feet of blood vessels, making it more sensative than fingertips, the head of the penis, or even the lips of the mouth. It is an important sourse of erotogenic, orgasim inducing sensations. Intact males are more sensative to the slightest touches, whereas the circumcised male has to work a bit harder to feel sensations, making circumcised males LESS likely to wear a condom during sex because it inhibits pleasure. The foreskin also acts a a self-lubracant during mastubation and sex, causing less vaginal dryness and taking out the need for using lube.
Myth #4- Preventing urinary tract infections? Not so much. Sure there are rumors, but now the AAP knows that any benfits to circumcision in prevention to UTI's is very small, and only for the first 6 months of life. UTI's are actually more common in wome, there's about a 900x greater likelihood.(yet we still don't approve of circumcising our little girls)
Myth #5- Contrary to popular belief, no, not every boy is circumcised. Only 15% of males world wide have a circumcised penis, and in America it's about 60% but it's decreasing every year. And who cares if he doesn't look the everyone else? SInce when have we approved of getting a cosmetic procedure done for our kids just so they will "fit in"? Don't get me wrong, I dread the day that my son comes home from school sad because someone made fun of him, but that doesn't mean that I am going to rush off and get him a procedure to fix it. I empathize, but I am not going to send the message that it's ok to get an unnecessary and risky surgery just because of peer pressure. I wouldn't give him a nose job, and if I had a girl I wouldn't get her a boob job, I would teach them how to respect their bodies to the best of my ability. People need to realized that circumcised or not, your kid will be picked on for some reason, that's just how kids are. It's an unfortunate part of society. And for the whole thing about women preferring a circumcised penis, I'm sure that's true, for SOME women. Not everyone has the same preferences. And if a person is shallow enough to break up with a guy just because he isn't circumcised, well that's not really much of a loss on his end is it? Some people will ask if I feel bad at all at the potential of my son getting teased...well sure I do. But I don't feel half as bad for that, as I do for the 200-300 baby boys who will die each year due to circumcision complications.
Myth #6- People think that if their baby gets a local anesthetic(which most babies don't) that the procedure doesn't hurt the baby. Which I'm sure it's true, party. You forget that the actual injection itself hurts the baby, and that the anesthetic wears off very shortly after, and postoperative pain last for days. Not to mention the pain of constantly rubbing up against a diaper full of pee and poo. Studies indicate that those babies who appear to sleep through a circumcision have most likely slipped into a semicomatose state, and a slew of recent studies on newborns, traumatic experience and sensory perception support this hypothesis. And for the people who say that it's ok because he won't remember it...um..so are you telling me that it would be ok if your child got hit by a car because he or she wont remember it?? Regardless of the memory, they are still going to go through the pain, and nothing about that is ok. At least not to me. How many women who get their sons circumcised actually sit in there with their little babies? I find it shocking how many don't because they "can't take it", well imagine how he feels. Just being born and learning how to trust and then strapped down to a table and has a chunk or highly sensitive skin cut off. The procedure can be so traumatic for some babies that it disrupts feeding habits and interferes with the mother-baby bonding process.
Myth #7- Sure some studies show a slight difference in STDs and AIDS in circumcised and uncircumcised males, but other studies show an opposite effect, or one so insignificant that it really doesn't matter. "The US has the highest rate of medically unnecessary, non-therapeutic infant circumcision in the world - and yet the HIV infection rate in North America is twice the rate in Europe, where circumcision rates are low." (The Truth About Circumcision and HIV by Gussie Fauntleroy) What it comes down to is wearing a condom, practicing safe sex. NOT circumcision status.
Myth #8 I'm sure you've heard that circumcision prevents a form of penile cancer, but according to a letter from the American Cancer Society (National Home Office) to the American Academy of Pediatrics on Feb 16th 1996, "The American Cancer Society does not consider routine circumcision to be a valid or effective measure to prevent such cancers... Penile cancer is an extremely rare condition, affecting one in 200,000 men... Perpetrating the mistaken belief that circumcision prevents cancer is inappropriate". "Men have a higher chance of getting BREAST CANCER (0.7% likelihood) than they do of getting penile cancer (0.09%). To argue that circumcision decreases the rate of penile cancer is like arguing that if we keep kids locked inside their bedroom their whole life they won't get struck by lightening outside. It is absurd. Yes, if you cut an organ off your body, you will not ever get cancer in that organ. Cut off the breasts, we will not get breast cancer. Skin a person, and we won't see melanoma. Maybe we should severe all organs & limbs & live as vegetables." (http://www.drmomma.org/2009/10/dads-view-of-circumcision.html)
Myth #9- Most people think that non-religious circumcisions are based on disease prevention, but that's not the case. Non-ritual circumcision evolved from a misunderstanding of bodily function by physicians of the late-19th century. Many doctors of that era believed that a normal foreskin could cause disease and lead to increased incidence of “self-abuse.” John Harvey Kellogg, of cereal fame, was a proponent of genital cutting as a cure for this “horrible practice.” He recommended performing circumcision “without administering an anesthetic, as the pain attending the operation will have a salutary [health-giving] effect upon the mind, especially if connected with the idea of punishment.” (from Gollaher D. Circumcision: A History of the World’s Most Controversial Surgery, New York, Basic Books, 2000)
Myth #10- You shouldn't think of circumcision as a way to prevent it later in life. The truth of the matter is that medically necessary circumcisions are extremly rare. Any problem with the foreskin can almost always be treated using more conservative treatments.
If you stick to your belief that it is medically necessary, then by using this logic you should also believe in female circumcision. We use the same medical reasons to circumcise our sons that people over in Africa use to circumcise their daughters, yet the practice of female circumcision is illegal in America. Saying that it is healthier, more hygienic, and is more aesthetically pleasing. Even claiming that it also reduces the risk of getting HIV. I'm finding it hard to see why people have such a double standard to this.
"We either choose to acknowledge the right of bodily integrity, or we do not. If this is accepted as a basic human right, then it automatically applies equally to all humans, regardless of sex, religion, [age], or cultural background. If denied as a right to one group, it is not a right for all, but a special privilege guaranteed only to a protected class." ~ Evan Saveron
There are many reasons why I chose not to circumcise my son, but the biggest reason was it's simply just not my choice. It is HIS body, not mine. The procedure is being done on the only person who cannot consent to it. In no other practice would this be accepted. If we were to do this same procedure to a dog, cat, or any other mammal we would be charged with animal cruelty. Just because I think that you need liposuction, doesn't mean I have the right to make you get it. If he wants a circumcision when he is older, than I fully support his choice. And at least when he is older he will be able to be put under for the procedure and receive pain medication for afterwards. Circumcision is permanent, whereas if he isn't circumcised he can change that in the future. I would rather my son hate me for a moment (even though I highly doubt that he will if he is fully informed) and be able to change the choice I made for him than to hate me for a lifetime for making a choice that he is now stuck with forever.
Here are some helpful sites to check out if you are more interested.
http://www.nocircpa.org/4642.html
http://www.naturalchildbirth.org/natural/resources/newborn/newborn03.htm
http://www.drmomma.org/2009/09/functions-of-foreskin-purposes-of.html
http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/are-you-fully-informed.html
http://www.askdrsears.com/html/1/t012000.asp
http://circumcisiondecisionmaker.com/watch-circumcision-video/


